TAB LogoTAB
Creativity
Home›Priya Menon›The Art of Not Finishing: Notes from a Mumbai Local

The Art of Not Finishing: Notes from a Mumbai Local

The Art of Not Finishing: Notes from a Mumbai Local
P

Priya Menon

2w ago · 4 min read

Self-improvement without the hustle. Reflection over reaction.

The 7:14 Virar fast pulls out of Andheri station with a shudder that travels up your spine. Inside, a man in a faded blue shirt opens a notebook. He writes three lines, stops, looks out the window, and closes it. The notebook stays closed for the rest of the ride. He gets off at Borivali. I never see him again.

The myth of the finished thing

We are told that creative work must be completed. A novel needs a final chapter. A painting needs a signature. A song needs a fade-out. But the most alive things I have seen are the ones that refuse to end. A half-written notebook. A sketch with no background. A conversation that trails off because the train arrived.

Finishing is a kind of death. Not a bad death, but a death nonetheless. The moment you declare a thing done, it stops growing. It becomes a product. It enters the world of deadlines and feedback forms and what does this mean. Before that, it is just yours.

The local train as a studio

Consider the Mumbai local. It is a machine built for a single purpose: to move people from one point to another. And yet, inside it, people do the most unfinished things. They read a page and stare at the ceiling. They write a sentence and cross it out. They hum a tune that has no ending. The train does not ask them to finish. It only asks them to get off at the right stop.

I once watched a woman on the 8:32 Churchgate fast crochet a sleeve. She worked on it for four stops, then put it away. The sleeve was not attached to a sweater. It was just a sleeve, a tube of wool, and she seemed perfectly happy with that. She was not making a sweater. She was making a sleeve. The sweater was someone else's problem.

The rupee cost of completion

There is a price to finishing. Not just in time, but in money. A photographer I know in Delhi spent ₹18,000 on a print of a photo she had already sold digitally. She wanted to see it framed. The frame cost more than the photo. She hung it on her wall and never looked at it again. The unfinished version, the one on her hard drive, still had a pulse. The framed one was a corpse in a nice suit.

This is not an argument for laziness. It is an argument for keeping some things open. A draft you return to is a conversation. A draft you finish is a monologue.

How to leave a thing unfinished

Not every project needs to be abandoned. But every project needs a door left ajar. Here is what I do: I stop before I am ready. When I know the next sentence, I stop writing. That way, when I come back, I have a thread to pull. The page is not cold. It is warm from the last touch.

The man on the 7:14 fast had it right. Three lines, a look out the window, and a closed notebook. He was not failing to write. He was writing in a way that left room for the next train. The notebook was not a failure. It was a promise.

The last station

The train pulls into Virar. Everyone gets off. The man with the notebook walks towards the exit, and I see him put the notebook in his back pocket. It is still there, still unfinished. He will open it tomorrow, on the same train, and write three more lines. Or he won't. Either way, the notebook is not a problem to be solved. It is a place to be.

The doors close. The train pulls out again, empty, ready for the next set of unfinished things.

Enjoyed this?

🎨
Creativity

Follow this topic — every new article & thread flows into your feed.

P

Written by

Priya Menon

Comments (0)

U

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!